Children, please turn away. I'm here to remind a nation about the specifics of Michael Vick's crimes. This is a man whose Bad Newz Kennels killed dogs by slamming them to the ground, shooting them with a .22-caliber pistol or electrocuting them. Or drowned dogs by shoving their heads into five-gallon buckets of water. Or hanged dogs via a nylon cord attached to two trees. Or approved of "a rape stand,'' used to strap down aggressive female dogs so male dogs could mount them.This was sick and twisted activity, the sort of disturbia that doesn't vanish from the American consciousness simply because Vick served 18 months in prison and the past two months in home confinement. Admittedly, I was very weirded out by the images Monday when Vick's federal dogfighting sentence ended and he became a free man, shedding the electronic monitor worn on his ankle. Not nearly enough time has passed for anyone with a heart, let alone an intense love of dogs, to forgive him for his warped behavior.
So, no, I won't be urging Roger Goodell to have mercy on Vick. Before the justice-minded NFL commissioner has any leniency in a case unprecedented for its gruesome, fan-unfriendly stench, Vick must prove for at least another year that he is contrite and a completely changed man. It's important that he has volunteered to work with the Humane Society. It's encouraging that he is seeking advice from Tony Dungy, the most respected man in pro football. It's a shame he is $20 million in debt after once signing a 10-year, $130 million contract. It's interesting that he's immersed in a $9-per-hour job with a Boys and Girls Club in his native Virginia, helping with health and fitness programs.
Let him adjust to life in a society that detests him. Let him pay more dues and reconstruct his image off the field. Let him play in the fledgling United Football League, a four-team circuit centered mostly around Thursday nights in October and November, which seems perfect for his circumstances and an outlet to show he still can be a big-time quarterback. But the NFL?
At this point, I'd be more inclined to give O.J. Simpson a shot. And by the sounds of it, Goodell has no interest in opening a hornet's nest when he meets with Vick in what the league discreetly is timetabling as the near future.
"I don't believe everybody deserves a second chance,'' the commissioner said recently. "It's not a right to play in the NFL. It's a privilege.
"What has he learned from this experience? Does he recognize the horrific mistakes he has made? Is he prepared to show genuine remorse and, most importantly, be a positive influence going forward? Michael's going to have to demonstrate that to myself, the general public and to a lot of people. Those are questions that I would like to see when I sit with him."
Thing is, such tough questions can't be answered in a matter of days. And it must be mentioned that the last time the two sat down, in April 2007, Vick lied to Goodell's face by denying any involvement in dogfighting brutality on his property. Yes, Vick has served his 20 months. But during that time, the commissioner has aggressively punished players who have violated the NFL's personal conduct policy, underlining that the league abides by its own justice system apart from the courtroom setting. He issued an indefinite suspension to Cleveland Browns receiver Donte' Stallworth after he killed a man while drinking and driving, ignoring a ridiculous Florida plea bargain that allowed Stallworth to pay the victim's family and serve only 24 days in jail. Chances are, Stallworth won't play in the league again.
If Vick doesn't play in the league again, I won't complain. At the very least, carry on with his own indefinite suspension. There are those who think killing a dog after an unsuccessful test fight is tolerable behavior, that Vick's case isn't as serious as Stallworth's case. Don't count me among them. "It is this barbarism that sets the crime apart," Ed Sayres, president of the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, told the Associated Press. "This was not a one-time transgression or crime of passion -- this was a multi-year pattern of behavior that demonstrates a startling lack of moral character and judgment."
With training camps ready to open, not one NFL team has acknowledged even the slightest willingness to sign Vick. His former coach in Atlanta and ongoing friend, Jim Mora Jr., has said he's rooting for Vick but won't sign him in his first season as head coach of the Seattle Seahawks. Bill Parcells is the type who might gamble, especially with the Miami Dolphins running a Wildcat offense very conducive to Vick's talents. But the Dolphins drafted a similarly athletic quarterback in Pat White, and the team says it isn't interested. Ditto for Tampa Bay, San Francisco, St. Louis and Cleveland. Even the Oakland Raiders, notorious for signing renegades, are said to have many dog-lovers in their management hierarchy -- who knew anyone working for Al Davis could have a heart? The owners of both New York franchises were asked Monday if they would pursue Vick. Their responses mirror the attitude of all teams.
"On a lot of levels, no," Giants owner John Mara said.
"We've got Kellen Clemens and now we have this young Mark Sanchez, and I think we are good on quarterbacks," said Jets owner Woody Johnson.
Plus, who knows if Vick still can play at a high level? Dangerous as he was as a runner and ad-libber, he also was an inaccurate passer who still hadn't mastered how to be an all-around quarterback. The Wildcat experiment makes the most sense, but only with a highly disciplined team coached by a strong presence. New England and Bill Belichick? Maybe someday. Not now.
Not nearly enough time has passed for anyone with a heart, let alone an intense love of dogs, to forgive [Vick] for his warped behavior.What makes sense is a continued healing process and a league allowing him to shed prison rust. Vick doesn't want to play in the UFL, but if he's a smart man, he'll swallow his pride and use it as an NFL showcase. His rights belong to the Orlando franchise. "One of the things that is important in our premier season is to showcase the quality of talent and the coaches, and to be able to show outstanding players who find themselves in this quagmire the NFL creates," commissioner Michael Huyghue said. "Michael Vick might be that kind of player because he is a phenomenal talent, but he is transitioning back into the NFL. Also gaining as much widespread exposure for our league as possible might be addressed with Michael Vick."
Said former NFL coach Dennis ("They are who we thought they were'') Green, coach of the UFL's San Francisco franchise: "What he did was very wrong, and he paid his debt to society. He was a model inmate; otherwise he never would have made it out from prison early. Now he has to show he loves the game and is a responsible citizen. You can't show you love the game if you're not able to play the game. So if Michael Vick were to say, 'I will play for not a lot of money,' well, hello. We're here. If he is not allowed back into the NFL and he wants to show he is a model citizen and he loves the game, there is not a better situation for him."
In the slowest part of the sports summer, Vick has become the biggest story. I trust that Goodell, the best commissioner going, will act quickly to place it on the back burner it deserves. I want my football season. I want my fixes with Jay Cutler, the Dallas Cowboys without Terrell Owens, the Buffalo Bills with Terrell Owens. I want my Atlanta Falcons, Donovan McNabb and Arizona Cardinals. I want my Pittsburgh Steelers and Tennessee Titans. I want my Peyton Manning with the window closing on Indianapolis. I even want my Brett Favre, sick as I am of the back-and-forth.
What I don't want is Michael Vick.
Not for another year, if ever.
Latest Michael Vick Images
Former Atlanta Falcon quarterback, Michael Vick, left, leaves federal court after a visit to the parole office in Norfolk, Va., Monday, July 20, 2009. Vick ended his federal dogfighting sentence Monday, freeing him to lobby for a return to the field. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
Former Atlanta Falcon quarterback, Michael Vick, left, arrives at federal court with his attorney Larry Woodward in Norfolk, Va., Monday, July 20, 2009. Vick ended his federal dogfighting sentence Monday, freeing him to lobby for a return to the field. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
Former Atlanta Falcon quarterback, Michael Vick, left, leaves federal court with his attorney Larry Woodward in Norfolk, Va., Monday, July 20, 2009. Vick ended his federal dogfighting sentence Monday, freeing him to lobby for a return to the field. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
Former Atlanta Falcons quarterback, Michael Vick, right, arrives at federal court with his attorney Larry Woodward in Norfolk, Va., Monday, July 20, 2009. Vick ended his federal sentence Monday. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
Former Atlanta Falcon quarterback, Michael Vick, left, arrives at federal court with his attorney Larry Woodward in Norfolk, Va., Monday, July 20, 2009. Vick ended his federal sentence Monday. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
Former Atlanta Falcon quarterback, Michael Vick, rear center, bids farewell to two federal probation officers at his in Hampton, Va., Monday, July 20, 2009. Vick ended his federal sentence Monday. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
A federal probation officer's car sits outside the home of former Atlanta Falcons quarterback, Michael Vick, in Hampton, Va., Monday, July 20, 2009. Vick ended his federal sentence Monday. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
Two federal probation officers leave the home of former Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Vick at his in Hampton, Va., Monday, July 20, 2009. Vick ended his federal sentence Monday. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
Former Atlanta Falcon quarterback, Michael Vick, rear center, bids farewell to two federal probation officers at his in Hampton, Va., Monday, July 20, 2009. Vick ended his federal sentence Monday. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
People wear Michael Vick jerseys as they wait for him to return to his home in Hampton, Virgina, from a federal prison in Kansas on Thursday, May 21, 2009, after serving part of his sentence on charges of running a dog fighting ring. He will spend more time under house arrest. (Diane Cebula/Newport News Daily Press/MCT)
MCT











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
7-20-2009 @ 11:06PM
Dr Huxtable said...
You think that killing a dog is as serious as killing a human while driving drunk and high? You're even dumber than I thought.
Reply
7-21-2009 @ 12:31AM
speedy said...
For one, Vick seemed to enjoy torchering the dogs! Had no reason to make anymore money that he was getting from his football contracts & endorsements!! $130 million from just football alone over 10 yrs! So he didn't need the money! He enjoyed seeing animals rip each other apart & if his dog lost him a lot of money, he would hang it, burn it, slam it again concrete,drown, & hang! I think you need to re read this article again ! Stallworth, made a mistake drinking & driving! No doubt about it! The outcome you can argue as being worst,because a human being has died. What Mike Vick did was just pure EVIL & a huge mistake! Stallworth, just made a mistake driving drunk! It's not like he got drunk, went into a car to seek people to drive over!! He didn't just do this once, he did it over and over again! Killing dogs with every different way he could do it! Obviously you never had a dog or any animal! Stallworth didn't drive away after he hit the guy. he stayed with him, waiting for the ambulance to arrive! Mike Vick has a Serial Murder mentality!! Simple as that! Accident vs repeated behavior of torching dogs! If it were up to me, i would have gave him life in prison, so he can think about what he did to those poor dogs!
Manslaughter vs dog slaughtering for years!!
7-21-2009 @ 12:44AM
Mr. Foster said...
People know that drunk driving can lead to a (average weight of 3500 lbs) at 35-70 mph on the streets or highway. So, if you do drink, drive and kill someone, you should get the 4 to 12 years in prison. He drank on purpose. He drove on purpose. He's a grown man. It was not a mistake. Calling it a mistake and brushing it off is part of the reason why people keep doing it.
7-21-2009 @ 2:25AM
dxlstnr said...
Dumb? I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and say this is a "difference of opinion". But really. And while killing someone with a car is inexcusable and ends a human life, in respects it doesn't compare to Vick's heinous killings.
7-20-2009 @ 11:13PM
casale838633 said...
Let the man play football. Michael Vick made a mistake and has paid for it, the time has come for us to put this behind us and move forward.
Reply
7-21-2009 @ 1:24AM
Rod said...
He did what he did over a period of time. He repeated the behavior. He would still be doing it if he were not caught. Playing in the NFL is a privlege not a right.
7-20-2009 @ 11:31PM
maximillion said...
Leave the man be!!! He made a mistake get over it. Others have killed ppl and got a lesser sentence. you didn't complain when he was playn good
Reply
7-20-2009 @ 11:37PM
tishimself4168 said...
and when she is not in heat does your friend strap her to a post so multiple dogs can mount her? who the hell would even think of something like this? surely nobody with a normal sense of decency. and surely not someone i would ever care to watch play football again.
Reply
7-20-2009 @ 11:51PM
nc0gnet0 said...
What Vick did was unforgivable, but please, don't make PETA the poster child for animal rights. PETA is as everybit convuluded as Vick, and will stop at nothing to pursue thier agenda, which would include many things most animal lovers would cringe at. Did you know PETA ultimate goal would lead to the extinction of all dogs and cats? Did you know PETA actually considered using Vick as a spokesman?
Reply
7-21-2009 @ 12:01AM
wleecia said...
PLEASE!!! I LOVE DOGS BETTER THAN THE NEXT PERSON!! BUT GET OFF IT...IF HE HAD KILLED A HUMAN BEING U WOULD HAVE NOTHING TO SAY!!! HE SERVED HIS TIME...HOPEFULLY HE HAS LEARNED FROM THIS & CAN GO ON AND TEACH OTHERS THAT HE MADE A MISTAKE AND THAT DOG FIGTHING IS VERY WRONG!!! CANNOT MAKE THIS MAN SUFFER A LIFE TIME FOR THIS!!! THANK GOODNESS SOME OF YOU PEOPLE ARE NOT GOD!! AND THANK GOODNESS GOD IS NOT LIKE MAN!!! UNFORGIVABLE! YEAH RIGHT!!! CAN YOU SAY NUT!!!
7-20-2009 @ 11:52PM
sittnontwenties said...
i am a dog owner and have had many through out the years he did his time paid the price for his crimes i personally think he should be allowed to play ball and as far as i can see i am not a porch monkey for supporting him either why does everything always come down to racism when a black man committs a crime what would he be if he were a white man amerikkka our great country
Reply
7-20-2009 @ 11:59PM
Michael Blake said...
The good thing is that you personally cannot stop him from returning to the NFL. GET OVER IT!!!!
Reply
7-21-2009 @ 12:12AM
Danielle said...
What an article! And thank you, Mariotti, by the way for the warning up front; the ickiness was gruesome, but you handled it well.
As for Vick, I see both sides. Yes he did HORRIFIC things, but he did pay his debt to society. I want to forgive without reservation, but the forgetting part is tricky in light of the heinous-ness of the crimes. The NFL is their own entity, and from a simply financial view, they would probably lose who knows how much money, how many viewers, etc., because not everyone is just going to be like the commenters I read before me. Some actually care about dogs and torture and would picket, boycott, etc. It doesn't look like Vick is going to have a lot of options. I hope he chooses wisely.
The thing you pointed out also re: did he have a change in himself, or is all of the make good stuff window dressing? Unfortunately, who knows. People who do those types of things aren't known for their spontaneous turnabouts of conscience, although, of course, anything's possible. And people who lie to cover up their behavior are, also unfortunately, all over the place in all segments of society.
Reply
7-21-2009 @ 12:16AM
Classius said...
Jay, I didn't even read the entire column. No need to. What Vick did was wrong on so many levels, but for you to say that the man deserves to have his God-given opportunity to make a living is completely wrong, if not reprehensible. The NFL is a league in which wife beaters, drug addicts, drunks, and alleged/convicted murderers (I don't care how you spin it, if you drive drunk and kill somebody, you're a murderer in my eyes. If I'd have done that, I'd be convicted as such because I'm not a multimillionaire; also, anybody remember the Ray Lewis accusation?) and you're actually arguing that Vick shouldn't get a second chance? Donte Stallworth KILLED A HUMAN BEING and got less than one month!
America is the land of second chances. Give Mike Vick a second chance. He actually paid his debt to society. Get off of your high horse.
Reply
7-21-2009 @ 12:17AM
V. Bruce Urie said...
"He made a MISTAKE?" It's NOT a mistake when this POS KNEW what he was doing was wrong, and HE DID, it's called pure black arrogance thug diva attitude! It's pure animal cruelty. You'd all sing a different tune if this POS treated your wives, girlfriends like this, wouldn't you? I thought human beings were "animals" also. Not like this sick POS who I'd love to beat the shit out of personally. Given the chance, I would in a heartbeat. I hope and pray he NEVER is plays any sports at all. He's a cruel, self-centered thug diva who should still be serving time where he belongs...in maximun lockup. God, what a loser! How can ANYONE feel sorry for this "poor boy" is beyond me. What a world.
Reply
7-21-2009 @ 12:17AM
dareed0305 said...
what he says is so similar to race relations spanning from today to after the civil war. If only he understand how backwards he actually sounds when talking about mike vick playing football. Dogs are property, If he is responsible for property he should be able to use his property to his discretion- if we compared this to slavery in any way. Anyways- there are people in the league who cheat on wifes, abuse their wives and children, sell and use drugs, kill and harm REAL PEOPLE... REAL PEOPLE!!!! and still play every down in the league. This man kills some dogs, and the whole world sees him as scum on the earth- all until he scores the GW touchdown for his team, then they will love him again. Mariotti has been fooled to dramatize everything about mike vick- what he fails to forget is... One ESPN highlight. people will no longer care, nor will remember any pistols put near any dogs
Reply
7-21-2009 @ 12:21AM
Bishop said...
I think your article is totally out of touch and shows what your true feelings are, and not just about Mike Vick... He served his time... Those were dogs... not humans... I wonder if you'd feel the same way if he's killed a human... I doubt it... I'm not into dog fighting... never have... never will... but it's not the same as killing people... no matter what PETA says... Let the man play Football...
Reply
7-21-2009 @ 12:27AM
dareed0305 said...
we are talking about a society where an entire basketball team starts beating the crap otu of REAL PEOPLE!!!! These are the same players that get an entire halftime show dedicated to them (Ron Artest). So when we talk about DOGS, whats the difference between a dog and a pig, a cow, or chicken- whom we slaughter recklessly...Listen oto how crazy you sound!! You probably have more to say about Miek Vick than hitler, Jim Crow laws, or terrorists.. Listen to how insane you sound.
Reply
7-21-2009 @ 12:47AM
opiccolo19 said...
let the dude play he did his time. that is enough punishment
Reply
7-21-2009 @ 12:51AM
biscuitnblues said...
I think a lot of people are missing the point. Whether you think the crime is horrible or not, its still a crime. Criminals should not get the priviledge of playing in the NFL. They had their chance to be in the special group, and the blew it. I say kick them all out and let the law-abiding men play.
I don't care about the players, I care about my team and the game. Players come and go, but the team remains. This should not even be debated. The NFL does not need people like Vick or Stallworth. There are plenty of quality players who are also quality people. Let them play and earn the big money.
Reply