I am heartened to know, as an American and a human being, that Roger Goodell has a strong sense of responsibility and pride when a courtroom in Miami has neither. Donte' Stallworth may have the money to buy himself out of a lengthy jail sentence, a despicable escape from a drunk-driving debacle in which he imbibed into the wee hours, had a .126 blood-alcohol level, foolishly drove his car and killed a pedestrian.But Goodell, the NFL boss who has no tolerance for ill social behavior, was quick to declare Thursday that he is among the outraged. Only two days after Stallworth plea-bargained a jail term that now will involve -- excuse me while I vomit -- a mere 24 days in the clink, Goodell informed the Cleveland Browns receiver that he has been suspended indefinitely without pay. I'm not sure what it says about criminal justice in dirty Dade County, Florida when a football commissioner cracks a tougher whip than a state attorney. But here's yet another example of why Goodell steadily is becoming the best administrator in professional sports.
To hell with local corruption. This judge makes his own rules.
"The conduct reflected in your guilty plea resulted in the tragic loss of life and was inexcusable," Goodell wrote in a letter to Stallworth. "While the criminal justice system has determined the legal consequences of this incident, it is my responsibility as commissioner to determine appropriate league discipline for your actions, which have caused irreparable harm to the victim and his family, your club, your fellow players and the NFL.
"There is no reasonable dispute that your continued eligibility for participation at this time would undermine the integrity of and public confidence in our league.''
Yes, Stallworth has to serve two years of house arrest and remain on probation for eight years after his 3 1/2 weeks of jail time. But if this were you or me or the guy walking down the street, we'd be in the slammer for months, if not years, regardless of any financial settlement with a family. Why Stallworth's generosity factored into a dramatically reduced jail term, I can't explain -- other than to suggest that an investigation of all parties be launched. But part of Stallworth's stunning deal with the court included an immediate continuation of his football career.
That won't be happening anytime soon. The thinking in league circles is that Stallworth's ban could extend through the entire 2009 season, which means the Browns are expected to release him. This after a $4.5 million roster bonus kicked in for Stallworth the night before the crash that killed 59-year-old Mario Reyes, a construction worker and family man who was finishing a shift and rushing to catch a bus when hit by Stallworth's black Bentley on MacArthur Causeway. Only the Browns, one of the NFL's most luckless and hapless franchises, could lose $4.5 million while a player is pleading guilty to DUI manslaughter -- a salary-cap mess that surely will be addressed with Goodell now that Stallworth is unavailable.
Sadly, there is a precedent for a drunk-driving fatality involving an NFL player. In 1999, Leonard Little was suspended eight games after pleading guilty to involuntary manslaughter for killing a woman while driving drunk. But the Goodell Era has been dominated by the commissioner's swift and relentless crackdowns on player conduct, meaning we can expect a longer suspension for Stallworth. He reportedly was in the league's substance-abuse program in 2007, and with the new drunk-driving case counting as a second violation, he'll receive a mandatory four-game suspension for that offense alone. This is what we love about Goodell, his will to protect the league from problem children. Whether it's Michael Vick murdering dogs, Pacman Jones wreaking havoc or Stallworth killing a pedestrian, the NFL's image always comes first.
"DUI is a serious matter which poses great risks to both those who drive under the influence, and innocent third parties. This truth was tragically underscored in Mr. Stallworth's case,'' Goodell wrote Thursday in a memo to the league's 32 teams, obtained by ESPN. "In the past few years, I have not hesitated to impose discipline, including suspensions, on club and league employees who have violated the law relating to alcohol use. Every club should advise its employees of their obligations and our commitment to hold people accountable for alcohol-related violations of law.
"Let's make sure that the 2009 season does not bring more tragedy or embarrassment to ourselves and our employees."
Supporters of Stallworth -- the few who are out there -- say he deserves credit based on his cooperation with authorities and the way he reached out to the Reyes family. They say he flashed his lights at Reyes when he saw the man dashing toward the bus. They say he stayed at the crime scene and reported the accident. They point out that his driver's license has been suspended for life and that he'll be performing 1,000 hours of community service. "I accept full responsibility for this horrible tragedy," Stallworth said. "I will bear this burden for the rest of my life."He also should have carried the burden of significant jail time. Vick spent two years in jail for his mauling, drowning and shooting of dogs -- so when Stallworth serves only 24 days, does that mean we value dogs as a society more than a fellow human being who is killed? Sure seems that way. When Little received a 90-day sentence for killing Susan Gutweiler, many in St. Louis protested the punishment was too light. Now, compared to the Stallworth sentence, it's Little who has the rightful complaint.
Just as NFL teams will have to consider the wicked public-relations fallout when contemplating Vick, Stallworth becomes a marked man in the league. I'm just amazed the Browns keep having to deal with such trauma. If it isn't staph infections at their training facility, it's a major shakeup in the coaching and general managing ranks. If it isn't Braylon Edwards dropping balls, it's Kellen Winslow ripping management and being traded. In 2007, they were the new darlings of the league. In 2008, they were frauds. Now, without Edwards, who had been on the trading block, they will hope rookies such as Brian Robiskie and Mohamed Massaquoi and veterans David Patten and Mike Furrey can help Brady Quinn grow as a young quarterback.
The lesson, of course, is to not sit behind the wheel of an automobile after you've been drinking. It's one of life's cardinal sins, as most courts acknowledge. Because a court in Miami somehow equated personal wealth with contrition, Stallworth will have a brief jail experience when he deserves months upon months of hell. Fortunately, Goodell swooped in with the more appropriate hammer.
In his next life, he can be a state attorney in Florida.











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 4)
6-18-2009 @ 10:09PM
Jose Perez said...
This is a tragedy. Drinking and driving needs to have tougher consequences but if Stallworth reached a financial settlement with the victims family, why does the commissioner think there should be more punishment. He is Fidel Goodell!!!! Stallworth is a first time offender and he hasn't been in trouble with the law. He wasn't like Michael Vick denying the whole incident and lying to the feds. He was remorseful from the beginning and accepted responsibility from the start. Plus, it has to be taken into account that the victim was crossing the street at an illegal crosswalk. My heart goes out to the victims family because they didn't deserve the pain but Stallworth paid his debt to the victims family and they reached a settlement. Goodell doesn't have punishment guidelines. If the judicial system gave Stallworth 30 days in jail, removed his lisence, gave him 10 years probation, plus the victims family settled and the court heard all the facts then we have to accept it. Lets go after the judicial system or the laws in place regarding drinking and driving, they are too light.
Reply
6-18-2009 @ 10:43PM
mordess said...
One way to "go after" the judicial system in Florida (if we can call it that) is to embarrass it -- and hopefully, Goodell's suspension will not only serve the purpose of minimal justice, but of embarrassment as well.
6-19-2009 @ 8:50AM
Sammy said...
Jose, drinking and driving does have harsh penalties. Loss of freedom, loss of driving privileges and many other things, as punishment. Just because this man had the money to pay his way out of the crime he committed does not make it right for him to do so.
Was it right for Ted Kennedy to only be charged with leaving the scene of an accident after he drove off that Chappiquiddic bridge?
In 1993 a young woman in Columbia South Carolina made the decision to drive drunk and she struck and killed another young woman who was jaywalking. She got years in prison, I don't know if she is out even now, 16 years later. Would it have been right for the driver to have only served 24 days in jail?
The fact remains, he took a human life. Why did he not hit his brakes and stop the car? Instead he flashed his light to try to make the man get out of his way. That act alone shows he had time to think and do something to prevent this tragedy. 24 days in jail is not enough punishment, no matter how much money he has.
6-19-2009 @ 11:37AM
matthew12678 said...
The commissioner absolutely has the right to suspend Stallworth. People lose their jobs for less severe offenses everyday. I would lose my 40,000 dollar a year job for a dui conviction, nevermind a manslughter charge. If you honestly think that Stallworth is being treated too harshly you have alot of problems. It is insane to feel sorry for Stallworth, money can't buy back a man's life and if the family settled that's their business, we're in a recession and most people are broke. As commissioner Goodell has every right to suspend Stallworth for a felony conviction. Smarten Up!!!!
6-19-2009 @ 12:15PM
Nicole said...
hello... jose.. question.. does money or remorse bring a person back?? no you moron.. it does not.. the legal system is messed up, true and although he may have done the right thing he still can not bring this man back to his family. i feel the justice system failed this man and family and if the nfl is stepping up to punish him so be it.. we should pat him on the back and thank him for staying at the crime scene, i really don't think so.. community service, money and house arrest can never bring this family justice!
6-19-2009 @ 6:10PM
Tom Maxfield said...
Jose; You must of went to school on the short bus. HELLO, He killed someone! If that was you or I we would be stocking up on K-Y jelly.
6-19-2009 @ 6:54PM
heenie said...
See how ignorant you are....Stallworth DOES have a previous history of substance abuse, in 2007 the league had him in a substance abuse program...DO YOUR HOMEWORK before you run your pie hole! Furthermore, for you to comment that Stallworth has "paid his dues" to his crime..those words in of itself are a crime..a life was lost and Stallworth only paid a financial settlement "because he has the money" and spent a very minor amount of time in jail to "think" about his criminal actions. I do feel the sentence was light and Goodell IS the commisioner of the league of which Stallworth is employed...therefore is it to his discretion of the punishment his wishes to extend to his employee. He is probably exhausted of the thug reputation of the NFL and knows young kids look up to these atheletes for motivation and guidence. So please, before you spout off, know your facts, know the law (of which was violated in regards to Florida's DUI codes) and have some compassion for others who may have lost loved ones and feel 24 days in jail is not adequet pain for the perp.
7-03-2009 @ 6:11PM
hartpinto said...
Perez are you that big of an idiot please,,
6-18-2009 @ 10:30PM
John Butler said...
Honestly players need to realize their in the spotlight and make better decisions, so if this type of action convinces them to do so i'm all for it driving drunk should recquire some suspension... but i feel that intent should be a big part of the law so driving drunk and someone being in the way of this should be treated the same if intent is proven to be innocent of the murder which in this case it clearly is when you look at the facts
Reply
6-18-2009 @ 11:05PM
Michael gifford said...
what will make this case even more absurd is if the players union goes to court to fight his suspension without pay...that will simply show that the union cares nothing for the guy who died and is simply focused on money for their players and their subsequent cut that comes from dues, etc. Can't wait to watch this one play out...as for the question of intent, manslaughter is manslaughter, voluntary or not, and one is not absolved of manslaughter just because he was drunk and had no 'intent' to do him harm...if a person drives drunk, they are already demonstrating the intent to not give a shit about another's human life...
Reply
6-19-2009 @ 12:50PM
Lynne said...
Of course the NFLPA is supposed to be more concerned with the players they represent. DUH.
6-18-2009 @ 11:24PM
Mark said...
This clown should never be allowed to play again. and if he actually has any of that signing bonus left it should go to the family of the man he killed. 24 days for taking a human life....BS BS BS
I wonder how quick some of these bleeding hearts would be quick to forgive him if it was one of their family members this piece of crap killed.
I've never been in trouble with the law so I should be able to get drunk and kill someone and only get 24 days in jail? Doubt it would work that way and it shouldnt. 24 days in jail for drunk driving alone isnt enough much less accident resulting in a death
Reply
6-19-2009 @ 11:32PM
ohiorook said...
The family of the man who was killed wanted the whole incident over with they knew what the punishment was going to be, you aren't reading about them complaining anywhere are you? So I guess the bleeding hearts who had a family member killed are ok with the verdict.
6-19-2009 @ 12:17AM
horatiowrd said...
Chris Henry's "indefinte suspension" was 8 games, or 2 months.
Yea, "get tough" indeed.
Reply
6-19-2009 @ 12:22AM
Adam said...
Donte was driving 50 mph in a 40 mph zone. That is to say, the way most people drive, he was not speeding. Everywhere I go, everyone is 10-15 mph over the speed limit. He was not out of his lane. The man went in front of his car. It's horrible, but Leonard Little ran a red light, hit the woman, and yelled, "you crazy bitch" at her. Donte should not have been drinking and driving. But once Mike Ditka remarked about a similar accident, "There but for the grace of God go I."
Reply
6-19-2009 @ 2:05AM
thetrutheh said...
at least goodell has enough integrity to do the right thing, unlike the corrupt commissioners of the NHL and MLB.
Reply
6-19-2009 @ 3:58AM
agselman3 said...
MARIOTTI YOU ARE AN IDIOT . THE MAN WALKED INTO THE STREET INTO THE PATH OF STALLWORTH'S CAR .THE ONLY THING STALLWORTH IS GUILTY OF IS DUI. GET THE FACTS STRAIGHT MORON . ITS NOT LIKE HE RAN PEOPLE OVER ON THE SIDEWALK OR SOMETHING.GET REAL.
Reply
6-19-2009 @ 4:10AM
will said...
Mariotti, you state that if you, me or the guy crossing the street had been the one behind the wheel we would have been thrown in the slammer.
Yeah right, this is another painful, disgusting ploy by you to appear to care for the common man; to perpetuate the myth that you are one of us. Nothing could be further from the truth, you are an elitist, plain and simple.
Case in point, a court system has issued out a sentence, but it is not good enough for good ol Mariotti, he has to pile on and demand punitive damages. What makes you think that you are better than the florida prosecutor? I bet the da has never been pwned by Woody Paige, or appeared on national tv with a clear case of male pattern baldness.
You have a lot to learn if you want to become a real american you hollywood elitist.
p.s. didn't you use to make fun of bloggers, you two faced hypocrite? Have fun in your moms basement.
-will
Reply
6-19-2009 @ 11:42AM
bkind7x said...
(Will) actully, my point in being on here is to - open people's eyes who can only see one side of a thing. You are not one of the people who will listen - to anyone's point of view - and you have continually, twisted and misquoted me / which is called "bearing false witness" - Will I have seen how you have spoken to other people on here (not just to me) - you are only here to harass, intimidate, lie, and bully people - that is called "terrorism". There is nothing I or anyone can do about it - but just between you and me - we both know what you are about; do you care about your future or anyone elses - no. Does that mean you don't have a future - no, but as of now you obviously don't care about one.
6-19-2009 @ 12:41PM
bkind7x said...
Your a smart guy / more quick witted than myself - you are smart enough to know you have not caught me in a lie, and to know I have not lied about anything - I will not waste my time proving your false judgement of me incorrect. However, I will let you know - you have helped me realize I do need to be more specific / in order to be more effective in my comments. I am not Einstein, but open mindedness goes a long way, and I am healing up from wisdom teeth extractions 1 week and 2 days ago - so I expect my concentration to be at least a little improved in what I am writing. But most importantly, writing error's or not - is that my VOTE is seen I AM A VOTE FOR THE REINSTATEMENT OF MICHAEL VICK INTO THE NFL. So far as the Stallworth case - I am sorry that someone died, and I feel for the family, but I also am considerate of Stallworth since the man apparently ran out in front of the car - so, I also feel for the "Judge" and for Goodell and all who have to make decisions on such a tough call; and I like to bring out the logic, truth, reality, when issues come up that can affect a lot of people. Plus I like football - and that is no secret - so, this is one forum I put some time into; but if it were the man working "down the street" at the paint shop who was in the same shoes as Michael Vick and served his time in a correctional facility - I would argue the very same thing for him - let the man work - SECOND CHANCES.