Controversies Under Bud Selig
MLB commissioner Bud Selig is getting plenty of attention again, this time for saying that he'll consider suspending Alex Rodriguez and restoring Hank Aaron as the home run king in the wake of the sport's latest steroid bombshell. Click through the gallery to see some of his most controversial moments.
Elsa, Getty Images
Selig has drawn the most criticism for turning a blind eye to the rampant use of performance-enhancing drugs in the game during the 1990s and early 2000s. The widespread use of steroids and other drugs helped rewrite many of baseball's most hallowed records and brought the nation's pastime into the halls of the U.S. Congress on multiple occasions.
Scott J. Ferrell, Congressional Quarterly / Getty Images
Selig suspended Game 5 of the 2008 World Series in the middle of the sixth innning with the Rays and Phillies tied at 2-all. The teams played several innings in a downpour with Philadelphia leading. Though Selig claims he would not have allowed the Phillies to clinch the title in a rain-shortened game, he made the decision to halt play only when it could be suspended under MLB rules. (Read MLB Rule)
Jed Jacobsohn, Getty Images
Under heavy pressure after a series of incorrect home run calls, Selig instituted instant replay this August on boundary plays -- those that involve home runs and the foul pole. Major League Baseball could be pressured to expand video replay further in the wake of a number of botched calls in this year's Fall Classic.
J. Meric, Getty Images
The suspension of Game 5 isn't the only controversial in-game call Selig has had to make as commissioner. He declared the 2002 All-Star Game, which took place in his hometown of Milwaukee, a tie after the managers ran out of pitchers.
Darren Hauck, AP
Two years after taking over as acting commissioner, Selig oversaw one of the darkest moments in baseball history -- the 1994 player strike which forced him to cancel the World Series that year.
Getty Images
Selig also spearheaded a realignment movement and the addition of a wild-card spot in each league, which added two divisions and doubled the number of teams in the postseason each year. The Florida Marlins were the first wild-card team to win the World Series in 1997, pictured, and while it has increased interest in the sport, some purists dislike the fact that a team that didn't win its division can capture baseball's ultimate prize.
Getty Images
In 1997, Selig helped introduce interleague play. While interleague matchups have likely helped drive some of the record attendance numbers in the last decade, it has also been received poorly by baseball purists.
Jim McIsaac, Getty Images
This is a man so big on spinning the truth and so small on actual results, we've even caught Selig in his own A-Rod moment. In a story published Thursday in USA Today, the commissioner said he sent an official "bulletin" about the illegal nature of steroids in 1997. The problem with that? Selig already was on record as saying he'd heard no discussion about steroids until 1998 or 1999, which means either his memory is foggy or his nose is growing -- probably the latter.
"I never even heard about it. I ran a team [the Milwaukee Brewers], and nobody was closer to their players. And I never heard any comment from them. It wasn't until 1998 or '99 that I heard the discussion," Selig said four years ago in San Francisco.
Oh, but there's more. How could he not have heard the discussion until 1998 or '99 when in July of 1995, in the Los Angeles Times, the commissioner acknowledged to baseball writer Bob Nightengale that the steroid issue was addressed by Selig and the owners as far back as a year to 18 months earlier, which now puts us in, um, early 1994. That's roughly when the roots of the steroids problem, according to timelines we've learned through the various investigations and confessions, began to explode. Yet Selig told the Times that he and the owners weren't worried in the least, even though the story suggested 10 to 20 percent of major leaguers were using steroids in claims supported by two general managers, Randy Smith and Kevin Malone, and anti-steroid superstars Tony Gwynn and Frank Thomas.
"If baseball has a problem, I must say candidly that we were not aware of it," Selig told the newspaper then. "It certainly hasn't been talked about much. But should we concern ourselves as an industry? I don't know. Maybe it's time to bring it up again."
Obviously, he didn't do that until it was much too late. And now, almost 14 years later, Selig is telling us that he's "heartsick" over the blockbuster that Rodriguez used steroids for at least three years, as if this development actually took him by surprise. "I am saddened by the revelations," Selig said Thursday in a statement, which, typically, came three days after Rodriguez's tell-all (tell-some?) interview. "What Alex did was wrong, and he will have to live with the damage he has done to his name and reputation."
At least Rodriguez had the guts, unlike Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens and Mark McGwire, to reveal himself as a steroid user and out himself as a liar. Selig has yet to issue his own apology to the public, instead painting himself as an innocent party who is so whiplashed by it all that he sounds like a jilted lover. "This is breaking my heart, I don't mind telling you," he said. Spare us the schmaltz and goo, commish.
Always more concerned about framing his legacy than doing his job, Selig should know right here, right now, how his legacy will read.
He'll be forever remembered as the Commissioner of the Steroid Era, a slick Mr. Magoo, the man who enabled a sad, repulsive era in sports history because he and the owners -- who pushed out independent commissioner Fay Vincent in 1992 because they wanted the power -- allowed the syringes and juice to happen under their greedy noses.
Selig and his supporters like to trumpet how he straightened out the game's economics, lifted its popularity and created new attendance records, which is exactly my point. Selig was so wrapped up in making money, he grew purposely blind to the steroids that produced the power numbers, thus awakening baseball from its post-strike attention rut.
It's clear, based on the Times story in '95, that Selig was aware of steroids then and there. It's also clear he sat back, loved watching the Home Run Derby drama between McGwire and Sammy Sosa and was too mesmerized by the cha-chinging to care that Bonds and so many others were juicing, too. When Major League Baseball finally wielded some clout and instituted survey testing for steroids, it was 2003, well into Rodriguez's "experimentation" phase.
Selig took WAY ... TOO ... DAMN ... LONG. Hence, I've written often that he should step down as commissioner, knowing that the owners are too lined with baseball riches to ever consider firing him. Whatever contributions he has made in fixing the sport's financial health are offset by his hideous, see-no-evil handling of the steroids ills that have spanned his commissionership. The owners pretend to care about the steroids crisis, but they are much more appreciative of his business acumen, to the point he received -- reach for the vomit bag -- an $18.5 million salary last year. If President Obama is cracking down on excessive wages for executives, he should start with Bud Lite.
Maybe Scott Van Pelt took Bud-bashing a bit far when he described Selig as a pimp on ESPN Radio, then belittled him as "someone who looks like a computer programmer, substitute teacher or government worker" and has a house that features "plastic on sofas, and it would smell bad." Also, he said Selig "has a chalice with 'B-U-D' spelled out in jewels and diamonds. You drink from a chalice if you're a pimp."
Yet it's understandable why Selig evokes such outrage in media and fans alike. The man in charge of the game, the man who had the gall with Jerry Reinsdorf to push Vincent out of office, did absolutely nothing as the biggest scandal ever in American sports unfolded before him. What nerve to actually suggest Wednesday, before thinking better, that he might suspend A-Rod, telling USA Today, "It was against the law, so I would have to think about that. It's very hard. I've got to think about all that kind of stuff."
Why weren't you thinking about "all that kind of stuff" before, Bud? When Rodriguez describes the early part of this decade as "a loosey-goosey era" for steroids, where, oh, where were you?It's a little too late for justice. You can't suspend Rodriguez now for one simple reason: It would discourage steroids users from coming forward and spilling their guts. What we want now is the whole truth and nothing but the truth, a complete explanation of the Steroid Era -- who, what, when, where and why. I want to know all the players who used, including the other 103 on the A-Rod list. I want executives and managers to explain what they knew. I want players to describe the era, specify how often they used steroids and how they obtained the drugs. And I want Selig and the union creeps, Don Fehr and Gene Orza, to be summoned to Capitol Hill and forced to explain what they really knew and why there wasn't a strong effort to end the steroids craze. I think we all know the answer: M-O-N-E-Y.
But I want to hear Bud say it.
And then he can get the hell out of the game, immediately, so baseball has a chance of preventing another steroids crisis in coming years.
The one good deed he can perform before going away is separating the Steroid Era from others in history, so Henry Aaron can remain the official home run king and the likes of Bonds and Rodriguez can be blackballed in the books. Selig says he'll consider reinstating his pal, Aaron, as the record-holder -- but his words are accompanied by the usual wishy-washiness. "Once you start tinkering, you can create more problems," Selig told USA Today. "But I'm not dismissing it. I'm concerned. I'd like to get some more evidence."
What more could he possibly need?











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
2-13-2009 @ 3:17AM
max jimenez said...
dear aol; please fire jay m. reading/listening to him is like trying to eat taffy/twizzlers or other things that just disgust but they seem to be everywhere. but maybe i'm too lazy to turn him off the tube..let alone the computer too!
Reply
2-13-2009 @ 4:52AM
joe and wendy said...
Iagree with you, however you can't take Bonds stats away because you don't know who all was juiced. How many of Bonds,A-rod,Sosa,Big Mac's long balls were hit off pitchers who were artificialy pumped up? If you start changing stats how about starting with taking away all homers hit since all ths fences have been moved in, or pitching stats since they tinkered with the mound and the strike zone expanded!Baseball has not been tainted because of roids, it's entertainment. Think about how baseball gushes over Babe Ruth, yet there is no talk of him racking up all those great numbers when black players weren't allowed to play? Now that's when the game was tainted!
Reply
2-14-2009 @ 6:17PM
dude said...
wouldn't it be funny if you were the joe and wendy from toledo that i know? that said, baseball is a GAME. i don't really care if someone cheated at a game. if i see someone cheat at a game of scrabble, i'm not taking them in front of congress. after all, it's only a game.
2-13-2009 @ 5:20AM
Crash173 said...
Selig is not to blame, the players who took the drugs are. If Mariotti wants to put the blame on someone other than the actual indiviuals that used the drugs, he should look at the MLB player's union. Where were they? Do you really think Selig could do anything without Donald Fehr's blessing?
Reply
2-13-2009 @ 5:27AM
Crash173 said...
Dear joe and wendy, Babe Ruth's stats stand the test of time when measured against all players of his generation, there is no question about that. What makes you think that racial disparities make any difference? How many great black pitchers do you think would have eliminated home runs from Babe Ruth? How many great black pitchers exist today? Oh you poor liberal guilt ridden buffoons.
Reply
2-13-2009 @ 8:38AM
ponzi scheme said...
you are a fool
2-15-2009 @ 12:32PM
joe and wendy said...
Crash173, My response had nothing to do with being either a leberal or a guilt ridden buffoon! But simply making a point, that baseball is a game knuclehead.Since your so smart, tell me what stains the game more. peds or not allowing a player to play because of skin color..DUH!
2-13-2009 @ 6:14AM
Grer The Sarcastic Bastard said...
Finally, people are staring to take the aptly named "Bud" to task. It takes incredible skill to lie through you teeth & talk out of both sides of your neck simultaneously. "Bud" has been trying to pull the wool over our eyes with his naivete' of what has been going on since the days of the Bash Brothers, and while players who get caught in lies are being read the riot act, very few have chosen to call out the commish. I would even accept a "Blind Eye" defense from him, because as we all know, it was all about the Benjamin's baby!!! You can't (and he won't) do anything to A-Rod because there was nothing in place in '01-'02, and 2003, like the upcoming 2010 cap-free year in the NFL, was a license from Mr. Selig for everybody to either clean up their act, or "act a fool." We see what 104 chose to do. I've said it before & I'll say it again, never trust a used car salesman named "Bud".
Reply
2-13-2009 @ 7:08AM
daytimedaddo said...
ok,i have it now...alex did steroids,and its baseballs fault...go figure...
Reply
2-13-2009 @ 8:19AM
oldmnscoot said...
Go hear the best hockey play by play man in the world. It's the funniest stuff you've ever heard. I guarantee it.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C3b_7S-sGBo
Reply
2-13-2009 @ 8:31AM
jhooperaa said...
Selig says A-Rod shamed the game? Does anyone think that back when McGuire, Bonds, Sosa, A-Rod, and all the other hitters were hitting 50-60-70+ homeruns that something was going on. Selig and the owners we all happy to have the attention on baseball and having attendance increase. Selig made $17,000,000 last year. If he never knew or suspected that steroids were prevelant in baseball he should be fired for stupidity.
Reply
2-13-2009 @ 8:32AM
manny said...
Bud,
You and the owners are to blame for this. You cannot change the rules in mid stream. You and the owners looked a blind eye at steroid use after the strike because it was good for the game and to bring it back. I am a Met fan and A-Rod is a Yankee but to suspend him because of a test when it was not rule illegal will be as much a sham as you saying you are the commissioner of baseball making 17.5 million last year to do nothing but shake your finger at those who play the game. With the great Babe Ruth being a loud Alcoholic was ok right?
Reply
2-13-2009 @ 9:05AM
keithstbird said...
All of this is bullshit i say bonds should keep the home run record like everone else has said steroids werent illegel back then so what if a-rod did steroids from 2001-2003 they werent illegel i dont understand this shit its all over tv its bullshit he came out said he did them that should be enough if it is that much of a problem take a-rods homeruns away from 01-03 and he will still break the home run record bud selig is a deuschbag hes a controdicting asshole that should be kicked out of baseball jay mariotti defenitly is right with this blog all selig cares about is the money
Reply
2-13-2009 @ 9:08AM
murph said...
my friends and i were chanting steriods at josie and big mac back in the bash brothers days. where was your outrage back then Jay? oh yea you were sucking up to players trying to make a name for yourself. dont you have a shrine to build to Brett Favre or something?
Reply
2-13-2009 @ 9:16AM
Fatman said...
Great article Jay........leave A-Rod alone, who gives a crap? It's not the same game anymore.....let's check the NFL or how about the corruption in Boxing.......and Basketball, what a joke. Lets make all records null and void. Any record after the retirement of Nolan Ryan should be put in a new record book. And as far as "Bud" Selig......he's the embarrassment in baseball, what has he done for the game, he's a creep....it's like having Montgomery Burns as the commisioner.
Reply
2-13-2009 @ 9:37AM
robben6138 said...
Selig is an incompetent.
He needs to shut up. Go away. I don't care all that much for A-Rod, but for this information to have leaked out, someone needs to go to jail...the leaker. This is a total abuse of power, and that's what Selig should be addressing.
Reply
2-13-2009 @ 9:45AM
Justin said...
Great article, Jay. Seriously, who does Selig think he is, casting blame on someone else?
Reply
2-13-2009 @ 11:10AM
MrSkratch said...
Bud is a liar, the roid heads are liars, the whole game of baseball is a joke now a days. I feel sorry for the players that did it the right way. Now they are tied into the steriod era and will be questioned until the day they retire. Having said all that, the records should stay the same. The only reason why is because at times it was a level playing field. Certain pitchers and hitters were doing it. Baseball knew about it and did nothing about it. Baseball has become the WWE to me. Guys hopped up on roids and HGH, and records are pre-determined. Its a joke. Go red sox!
Reply
2-13-2009 @ 11:41AM
cubesq said...
I became aware of the problem of steroids in sports by reading Rick Telander's SI articles in the late 80's. I suppose that Selig, in his infinite wisdom, believed the problem was limited to college football. Bowie Kuhn may have had a ham-handed way of dealing with unpleasant things but at least he made the effort.
Reply
2-13-2009 @ 12:04PM
dinohealth said...
GREAT ARTICLE, AND ABOUT TIME WE STARTED PLACING THE BLAME WHERE IT BELONGS FOR THIS MESS: MLB AND CONGRESS! WHEN CITY HALL IS CORRUPT, YOU DO NOT GO AFTER THE CLERK! Leave the players alone, because they were playing by MLB unwritten tolerance in rules! All records stand as they are! New rules, NEW COMMISH, STRINGENT ENFORCEMENT, AND LET'S MOVE ON!!!!
Reply